Every conversation about switching from oil to a heat pump eventually comes down to arithmetic, and most of what gets thrown around online skips the actual math. Let's do it properly, with real current fuel prices and a representative southern NH home, so you can see exactly where the numbers come from instead of taking someone's word for it.
The current prices and the physics
As of the week of March 30, 2026, the U.S. Energy Information Administration's weekly heating oil and propane price survey put New England residential #2 heating oil at $5.407/gallon and residential propane at $3.780/gallon (both excluding tax). New Hampshire residential electricity runs around 25¢/kWh, which is roughly 24% above the national average: one of the reasons this comparison is closer here than in states with cheaper power.
The energy content we need to convert between fuels:
- #2 fuel oil: about 138,500 BTU per gallon
- Propane: about 91,500 BTU per gallon
- Electricity: 1 kWh = 3,412 BTU
The example: an 800-gallon-a-year oil home
Say a representative southern NH home burns 800 gallons of oil per season through an 80% AFUE boiler: a common efficiency for a boiler that's ten-plus years old. Delivered heat is what the house actually receives after combustion losses, so:
800 gal × 138,500 BTU/gal × 0.80 AFUE = 88,640,000 BTU delivered to the house over the season.
A heat pump doesn't burn fuel: it moves heat, and how much electrical input it needs to deliver that same 88.64 million BTU depends on its seasonal coefficient of performance (COP), which is simply the ratio of heat delivered to electricity consumed. At a seasonal COP of 2.8 ( a reasonable expectation for a cold-climate heat pump properly sized and commissioned for our 0°F design temperature) the electricity needed is:
88,640,000 BTU ÷ 3,412 BTU/kWh ÷ 2.8 COP ≈ 9,280 kWh
| Scenario | Fuel/energy used | Annual cost | vs. 80% AFUE oil baseline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oil boiler, 80% AFUE (baseline) | 800 gal | $4,326 | N/A |
| Oil boiler, 95% AFUE | 674 gal | $3,642 | saves $684 |
| Heat pump, seasonal COP 2.2 | 11,810 kWh | $2,953 | saves $1,373 |
| Heat pump, seasonal COP 2.8 | 9,280 kWh | $2,320 | saves $2,006 |
| Heat pump, seasonal COP 3.2 | 8,130 kWh | $2,033 | saves $2,293 |
Swipe to see the full table
A few things jump out. First, even a pessimistic COP of 2.2 ( which is more typical of an older or poorly commissioned heat pump than a properly installed cold-climate one) still beats the oil boiler at today's prices. Second, the spread between COP 2.2 and COP 3.2 is roughly $920/year, which is exactly why we spend so much time in other posts on correct sizing and commissioning: a badly set up heat pump can quietly erase a big chunk of the savings you were expecting. See our posts on Manual J sizing and cold-climate performance.
Third, a newer, high-efficiency 95% AFUE oil boiler narrows the gap considerably against the low end of heat pump performance, which is part of the honest picture below.
Where the breakeven actually sits
Using the 80% AFUE oil baseline and a COP 2.8 heat pump, oil and electric heat cost the same when electricity reaches roughly 47¢/kWh: nearly double today's ~25¢/kWh New Hampshire rate. At a more conservative COP of 2.2, that breakeven point drops to around 37¢/kWh. Either way, electricity would have to climb substantially, or heat pump performance would have to be quite poor, before oil becomes cheaper again at today's oil price. That said, oil and propane prices are volatile week to week: these EIA figures are a snapshot, not a permanent baseline, and it's worth rechecking current prices before making a final decision.
When switching is not the right call
The math above doesn't mean every oil home should convert immediately. A few situations where switching is a weaker deal:
- A nearly new, high-efficiency boiler. If you replaced your oil boiler in the last few years with a 90%+ AFUE unit, the fuel-cost gap closes and the payback on a full conversion stretches out considerably: pairing a heat pump alongside it as a hybrid system, rather than replacing it, is often the better move.
- An envelope that needs weatherization first. If the house is leaky and under-insulated, both the heating load and the cooling load are inflated, which means you're sizing and paying for equipment to fight a problem better solved with air sealing and insulation first.
- Insufficient electrical panel capacity. Some older panels don't have room for the added circuit(s) a heat pump system needs without a panel upgrade, which adds cost that should be part of the decision up front, not a surprise mid-project.
On the other side of the ledger, a heat pump also delivers air conditioning as part of the same equipment: something an oil boiler obviously can't do. If central air is part of the plan anyway, that shared equipment cost should be weighed against the oil system's heating-only role.
Rebates, accurately stated
This is a spot where a lot of marketing copy gets sloppy, so let's be precise. NHSaves offers $250 per ton for a ducted air-source heat pump. The much-repeated $2,000 per ton figure is real, but it only applies to ductless systems replacing electric resistance heat: baseboard or an electric furnace. An oil-heated home converting to a ducted or ductless heat pump does not qualify for that higher tier, because oil isn't electric resistance heat. On top of the NHSaves incentive, the New England Heat Pump Accelerator adds a point-of-sale discount of $650 per outdoor unit, up to two units per dwelling. Full current details are on our rebates page.
One more thing worth stating plainly: the federal Section 25C tax credit for heat pumps ended on December 31, 2025 and does not exist for equipment installed in 2026. If you've seen a "30% federal tax credit" claim anywhere recently, it's out of date: see our page on what changed for the full explanation.
For more about this work, see our Heat Pump Installation in southern NH page or request a free estimate.
Dana Borriello: Dana Borriello founded Service One Heating and Cooling in 2013 and still runs service calls across southern New Hampshire. He writes here about the questions homeowners actually ask on the truck.
