Heat Pump vs. Oil Heat: What Will It Actually Cost in New Hampshire?
Enter your own oil or propane usage and see the real annual cost comparison against a cold-climate heat pump, with the actual BTU, AFUE, and COP math shown, and the break-even electricity price that tells you how much rates could rise before oil wins again.
Your operating-cost calculator
Enter your actual oil or propane usage (or just your annual spend), and adjust the heat pump's seasonal COP to see how the comparison changes.
Use your own written estimate here: this figure is not a Service One quote.
At this electricity rate, the heat pump and your #2 heating oil system cost the same to run. Your current rate is 25.0¢/kWh: compare the two to see your margin of safety.
Delivered heat this year: 88.6 million BTU, based on 800 gallons × 138,500 BTU/gal × 80% AFUE. Figures are estimates for comparison, not a bid: every home's real usage varies with weather, thermostat habits, and duct losses.
How the math works
The comparison starts from the same place every fuel bill does: how much usable heat, in BTUs, did your home actually burn last year? A gallon of #2 heating oil contains about 138,500 BTU. A gallon of propane contains about 91,500 BTU. Neither number is opinion: they're the standard heat-content figures used industry-wide.
Not all of that heat reaches your rooms. An older oil furnace running at 80% AFUE (annual fuel utilization efficiency) delivers 80% of the fuel's heat content into your ducts or radiators; the other 20% goes up the flue. A high-efficiency furnace at 95% AFUE wastes far less. So delivered heat is: gallons × BTU per gallon × AFUE.
A heat pump doesn't burn fuel: it moves heat from outside air using electricity to run a compressor, and it moves more heat energy than the electrical energy it consumes. That ratio is the coefficient of performance, or COP. A COP of 3.0 means 1 unit of electricity moves 3 units of heat. Converting electricity to the same BTU units (1 kWh = 3,412 BTU), the electricity a heat pump needs to deliver the same heat is: delivered heat (BTU) ÷ (COP × 3,412), and that answer in kWh times your electric rate gives the heat pump's operating cost.
Seasonal COP, not a manufacturer's peak-condition number, is what matters for a fair comparison, because it already accounts for the fact that a heat pump works harder (and less efficiently) on the coldest nights of a New Hampshire winter than on a mild October morning.
Where the fuel prices come from
The defaults in the calculator above are the U.S. Energy Information Administration's weekly New England residential heating-fuel survey, week of March 30, 2026: #2 heating oil at $5.407/gal and residential propane at $3.780/gal, both excluding tax. The electricity default (about 25¢/kWh) reflects typical New Hampshire residential rates, which run roughly 24% above the national average.
| Fuel | Price | BTU/gal or kWh |
|---|---|---|
| #2 heating oil | $5.407/gal | 138,500 BTU/gal |
| Propane | $3.780/gal | 91,500 BTU/gal |
| Electricity (NH residential, approx.) | $0.25/kWh | 3,412 BTU/kWh |
Swipe to see the full table
When oil still wins
A heat pump isn't automatically the right call for every southern NH home. Here's when the arithmetic or the situation favors sticking with oil:
- Low electricity-to-fuel price ratio. If electric rates climb well above where they sit today, or oil prices fall, the math flips. Use the calculator's break-even electricity price to see exactly how much room you have before that happens for your own numbers.
- A young, high-efficiency boiler or furnace. If you replaced your oil system recently and it's a 95% AFUE unit with 15 or more years of service life left, the operating-cost savings from switching may not justify walking away from equipment that still has most of its useful life ahead.
- Poorly insulated homes. On the coldest design days, an undersized heat pump can struggle to keep up in a leaky or under-insulated house, forcing more reliance on backup heat than the annual average COP assumes.
- No electrical headroom. Homes with an older, fully loaded 100-amp panel may need a panel upgrade before a heat pump can be installed, adding cost that changes the payback math.
- Low real-world COP. An undersized unit, an oversized one that short-cycles, or a system with a sloppy refrigerant charge can run at a seasonal COP closer to 2.0 than 3.0: at that point the operating-cost advantage over oil can shrink or disappear, which is exactly why proper sizing and commissioning matter more than the brand on the box.
None of this shows up in a marketing brochure, but all of it shows up in a real electric bill: which is why we'd rather show you the calculator than a slogan.
The value the operating-cost math misses
An oil furnace only heats. A heat pump heats and cools, using the same outdoor unit and indoor coil or ductless heads. If your home currently relies on window units or has no central air, that's a real dollar value, a separate central AC install typically runs several thousand dollars, that a pure annual-operating-cost comparison doesn't capture at all.
Frequently asked
Usually, yes, at current NH prices (#2 oil around $5.41/gal, electricity around 25¢/kWh) a cold-climate heat pump running at a seasonal COP of 2.5–3.0 typically costs less per year than an oil furnace at 80% AFUE. The margin narrows at low COP or if electricity rates rise, so it's worth running your own numbers rather than trusting a rule of thumb.
A well-sized, properly commissioned cold-climate heat pump typically averages a seasonal COP of 2.5–3.2 across a New Hampshire winter, factoring in colder days when efficiency drops. Poorly sized or badly installed systems can average closer to 2.0. Ask your installer for the manufacturer's published HSPF2 rating and what seasonal COP that implies for your climate zone.
It depends on your oil price, AFUE, and COP: that's exactly what the break-even output in the calculator above shows for your own numbers. As a reference point, at $5.41/gal oil, 80% AFUE, and a 2.8 COP, the break-even electricity price is a bit above 30¢/kWh; above that rate, oil starts to win.
No. Most southern NH installs are hybrid systems: the heat pump handles the great majority of the heating season, and the existing oil or propane furnace stays in place as backup for the coldest nights and as a safety net if the heat pump ever needs service.
Yes, a heat pump cools in summer as well as it heats in winter, using the same outdoor unit and indoor coil or heads. For a home currently on oil heat with a separate window-unit or no central AC, that's a real value the operating-cost comparison above doesn't capture.
Sometimes. Ducted whole-home systems and multi-zone ductless systems draw more amperage than a single window AC. Homes with 100-amp panels that are already near capacity may need a panel upgrade before installation: Service One checks this during the in-home estimate.
It uses the correct fuel-value physics (BTU content per gallon, AFUE, and COP) but it's still a simplified annual model: it doesn't account for hour-by-hour temperature swings, duct losses, or your specific thermostat setpoints. Treat the output as a solid planning estimate, not a guaranteed bill.
Want a real quote to plug into the calculator?
Free in-home estimate with a written installed price and load calculation.
